Tolkien Tuesday #4

25 January 2022

It has been a day for maps, and for wondering – my favourite kind of day, full of dreaming and musing and flicking through books. Also a day for birds, for the bird feeder is full and the garden birds have been vocal in their appreciation, at least whilst I’m sitting down to write this week’s Tolkien Tuesday. And though the day has been cold and grey, it has been far from miserable as I look back over the pages of Lord of the Rings I have read since the last update…

The Reading, and Ensuing Thoughts

This week, I started Chapter 2, The Shadow of the Past. I’m about halfway through it, and it took a great deal of determination not to continue on to the end of the chapter, but seeing as though I have allocated two weeks per chapter, I will endeavour to do so, for as long as I can hold out.

Some standouts from this past week’s reading have to be Samwise Gamgee discussing the truth to be found in old stories, and Gandalf’s return after nine years since his last visit to Bag End.

Photo by Pixabay on

My favourite part though, has to be of the strange wayfarers passing along the old East-West Road, bringing with them news from beyond the Shire’s borders…As reader, I want to meet these people, to hear their conversations, and as a writer, I want to write their stories, to know where they are going and what they left behind.

Middle Earth Musings and Meditations

He looked at maps, and wondered what lay beyond their edges…”

(From Chapter 2, The Shadow of the Past, The Lord of the Rings by J. R. R. Tolkien)

I woke up this morning thinking of maps. I love maps. Looking at maps. Drawing maps. Wondering what can be found in those mysterious regions past the edge of the known world…

The quote above, written about Frodo, speaks to me, unsurprisingly. It speaks to me as a person: mankind has been fascinated by what they don’t yet know since the beginning of time. It speaks to me as a reader: what adventures are to be found in these unknown reaches of a real or imagined world, and what characters are going to be doing the exploring? It speaks to me as writer, and offers up so many questions: what do I think lies beyond this boundary of the known world? Are there monsters? Magic? Gods? Ghosts? Is the unknown any different to the known? Who will be brave enough to go there and find out? What will they encounter? What friendships will they forge? What enemy will be waiting for them? Will they return to tell their tales to those they left behind? How would such a journey change them? These are just a handful of the questions that whirl around my head when I look at a map.

Photo by Ylanite Koppens on

I also find myself wondering at the empty spaces within a drawn map. After all, not everything can and needs to be included. But that doesn’t mean there isn’t anything or anyone there. They are just not pertinent to the story and what is going on in the world at that time (at least not to the storyteller, and those involved with the story). Yet my mind wanders and wonders…

The drawing of a map, is a very good place to begin a new story. Once you can envisage a landscape, you can imagine people in it. And then you can wonder why they are there and what they are doing.

I thought I would finish off this section listing a few of my favourite maps from some of my other favourite books:

  • The maps of Kyralia and beyond, in Trudi Canavan’s wonderful The Black Magician Trilogy and The Traitor Spy Trilogy
  • The map from The Kingdoms of Thorn and Bone quartet by Greg Keyes
  • The wonderfully detailed maps of George R. R. Martin’s Westeros and beyond
  • The map of Narnia by C. S. Lewis (I love the map much more than the books, the reviews for which you can read over on my book review site, if you’re interested)
  • And I can’t possibly talk about maps without mentioning Crispina Kemp’s map of Lake of Skulls from her five book series, The Spinner’s Game


Inspired by all things maps, I spent a good deal of time this week, pouring over not only maps of Middle Earth, but also others from the list above. It was a wonderful reminder of why I love fantasy fiction so much.

The Lord of the Rings Question of the Week:

Following on from the discussion on maps, where, in the less frequently explored regions of Middle Earth (think: not journeyed to in either The Hobbit or The Lord of the Rings), would you like to visit / know more about / read stories set in?

There are a few places (all right, many, many places) I could pick, but my eye has recently been repeatedly drawn to Minhiriath, and covers the area of land between the Brandywine and Greyflood rivers. This area has such an interesting history, and it’s name is one of those that sounds melodic and roles off the tongue. Simply beautiful, yet with a darker past…

14 thoughts on “Tolkien Tuesday #4

  1. Oh you. You are definitely pushing me to start reading so I can follow along with you! So, only half a chapter per week? I can catch up, needless to say. I cannot answer your question this week as I am way not as familiar as you…

    Liked by 3 people

    • I’m having the same response, Dale — now I want to revisit the books again, because Sammi is pulling out all these details that I don’t remember! My first thought is that I couldn’t stop with just one chapter, but then, I’m always reading other books too, so this can be a quick break. And hey, only one chapter every two weeks? That’s a book club I might actually be able to keep up with! 😀

      Liked by 2 people

  2. You won’t be surprised to know I’ve a love of maps. Old maps especially. I love pouring over the earliest Ordnance Survey maps, and relate them in my mind to how the landscape is today. And I enjoy drawing them. (Really? Yes!)
    But where would I like to explore? Do you mind if I come along with you? River-lands are far more interesting that hilly-bits and mountains.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Not surprised in the least, Crispina 🙂

      Old Ordnance Survey maps really are a treasure. I love studying the names of places. Some are quite obvious in their connection to the land but others can be more obscure and mysterious…and that’s when the story ideas start flowing 🙂


  3. Once again you bring out parts of the story that I hadn’t remembered. Although now I’m thinking that perhaps I just have a very poor memory, and this will keep happening all year!

    I love the old maps, and fantasy maps, better than modern ones. All those parts that are unknown, unexplored. “Here be dragons” and all that — how mysterious and enticing! I can’t think of one specific place in Middle Earth to visit that isn’t already explored in the books, but I’m loving the other posters’ suggestions. Let’s get a road trip organized and go to ALL the places! ❤

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.