
~ 2 August 2022 ~
After a super long walk yesterday where we walked for miles and miles, which was finished off with a beautiful picnic and the most delicious strawberry milkshakes, today was definitely a day of rest, and peace, and putting my aching feet up while I read The Fellowship of the Ring and drunk lots of tea!
And, I think everyone already knows this, but I am really behind with comments at the moment (yet surprisingly up-to-date with reading Weekend Writing Prompt responses…) so I just want to thank everyone for their patience with me. You all are so wonderful π
The Reading, and Ensuing Thoughts
This week we concluded Book 2, Chapter 3: The Ring Goes South.
The company have left Rivendell and begin their journey heading south. Their aim is to stay west of the Mountains, hoping the more inhospitable terrain will afford them greater cover. To this end, they are travelling by night and resting during the day.
It is hard going, and not much happens for two weeks bar they slowly get closer and closer to the mountains. Then the weather changes and they get their first glimpse of three great peaks. They have reached Hollin, once known as Eregion, and it is here they first encounter trouble.
Flocks of birds are flying over the land, searching for something, and the implication to the company is clear: they will have to go carefully if they are to pass through this country unnoticed. This means no fires and no loud talking.
Gandalf and Aragorn have been having quiet conversations trying to pick their best route for crossing the mountains, one of which Frodo overhears. They can travel down the mountain range to the Gap of Rohan, which would take them and the ring too close to Saruman, so is discredited at once. There is the pass known as the Redhorn Gate in the shadow of Caradhras, which will be difficult given the time of year and thus the weather, (Gimli had earlier explained this mountain peak was known to the dwarves as “cruel Caradhras”). The last option is a dark and secret way, which Aragorn does not wish to consider unless there is no other way. And so they try the mountain pass…

However, the mountain seems to bear them ill-will and does not to wish to let them pass. A strange and deadly snowstorm cuts off their progress partway up. They survive the night, just, by drinking a cordial given to Gandalf by Elrond, and by Gandlaf using his powers to light a fire to keep the worst of the cold at bay. However, those watching the mountain will now know he is there.
Come morning, it is clear they cannot go on. Caradhras has beaten them. With difficulty, they retreat back down the mountain. Aragorn and Boromir have to fight their way through the snow that fell overnight, in order for the others to safely follow behind. As they are descending, the birds fly over again.
Although a lot of ground is covered in this chapter, it feels quite slow moving. The tension builds steadily, as does the undercurrent of animosity coming from the area – both from the mountain itself and just the general feeling of being watched – culminating in what appears to be an attack by Caradhras. Here, again, we have the natural world choosing to behave in a certain away as if sentient, reiterating some of the same themes we saw in the Old Forest.
Next week we begin Book 2, Chapter 4: A Journey In The Dark.
Middle Earth Musings and Meditations
One of the most fascinating aspects of this half of a chapter, I found, was how Tolkien used sound.
We are told by Legolas that much of landscape – the trees and the grass – no longer remember the race of Elves that once lived in the area. It is only the stones he hears recall them and lament their passing over the sea.
The silence of Hollin, as pointed out by Aragorn, is interesting in that it is the absence of something which heightens the tension in this passage, and helps forge the atmosphere they are experiencing. This silence is only broken by the voices of the company, which “seem to make the ground echo”, until the flocks of birds arrive and “one harsh croak” is heard.
Then, when the company are climbing up the mountain: “They heard eerie noises in the darkness round them…the sounds were those of shrill cries, and wild howls of laughter.” Indeed, Boromir goes on to say, “there are fell voices on the air”.
Elsewhere
Nothing to report here this week…
The Lord of the Rings Question of the Week:
Out of the three options discussed by Gandalf and Aragorn with regard to how they would cross the mountains, which one would you pick?
Hmm…first I’ll answer as if I know nothing that happens after this chapter. Well I probably wouldn’t pick something described as “dark and secret” without knowing a little more about it first. And, if it concerns Aragorn, it should make me wary to choose it. Also, I’m not sure I would try to climb and cross a mountain at night, in winter, even if the mountain in question wasn’t known to be of an evil temperament. Which leaves the Gap of Rohan and the dangerous proximity to Saruman…it really is a choice of nothing, isn’t it?
Now, as I do know what is coming, would my reasoning change? Yes…sort of. I love the next couple of chapters. I love a lot of the imagery, and just the scale of things. So, against my better judgement I guess, I would throw all caution to the wind and pick the “dark and secret” way, because it’s worth the danger to see what is there. Gosh, it’s hard to try and answer this without accidentally dropping spoilers π
You hit the nail on the head with the: “Although a lot of ground is covered in this chapter, it feels quite slow moving.” You can feel their struggle and the mountain definitely wishes them ill. I felt exhausted for them, especially the little Hobbits, truly at the mercy of the elements.
I hadn’t really paid attention to the fact that there was a lot of “sound” references but now agree with you!
It’s funny, (besides the fact I’ve forgotten) I would have chosen Redhorn Gate. There will be other things to challenge them, no doubt, but weather is a cruel one.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Yes, weather is a cruel challenge, and it’s interesting how Tolkien has used weather throughout the story so far to signify gentle, enjoyable passages of travel as well as the harder, more wearisome trials of their journey.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Very interesting!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Very interesting, I hadn’t really thought about the sounds – regarding the path to take, although traveling down the mountain range to the Gap of Rohan, would take them close to Saruman, it might be worth the risk as it wouldn’t be expected and it would e very exciting!
LikeLiked by 2 people
That’s a great point, Angela. It wouldn’t be expected and so might be worth the try! π
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thinking now that Tolkien made this section so “slow” and silent so we’d have no choice but to pick the “dark and secret” way.
LikeLiked by 2 people
I think you are right!
LikeLike
What a wonderful insight, L.K. I think you’re on to something there! π
LikeLiked by 1 person
Three terrible choices. They are doomed on matter which way they go really. I wouldn’t want the Ring to go too near Saruman as his desires are well known. I probably would have gone the way they went in the end. It provided secrecy for them and they may have made it through unscathed if it hadn’t been for Pippin throwing a stone down a well. Also seeing a lost Dwarven city would have been spectacular (if you were also doing a sightseeing trip).
LikeLiked by 2 people
By the way I really look forward to these posts.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Me too!
LikeLiked by 2 people
I’m so glad. I’m enjoying them so much and the discussion is fantastic. π
LikeLiked by 2 people
Shhhh!! We “don’t” know which way they are going yet π
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oops, my bad!
LikeLiked by 1 person
π Yeah, yeah… I’m teasing!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I meant: They are doomed no matter which they go really… I usually mix letters up due to my dyslexia, though I usually catch it before I post it.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I have to agree with you. There doesn’t seem to be a “right” way here and all three have their perils. I was thinking the same thing about Pippin – if he hadn’t thrown that stone, might they have managed to make it through without being spotted? I would definitely have loved to see a lost Dwarven city! That would be a wonderful place to explore… π
LikeLiked by 1 person
Even with knowing what’s to happen I would chose the Gap. Solid ground beneath the feet, favourable weather, light. All is preferable to mountains, avalanches and nasty dark tunnels which might harbour who knows what
LikeLiked by 3 people
Agreed!!
LikeLiked by 2 people
πβπβπβ
LikeLiked by 1 person
π
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes, there is definitely some sense in that option, and as Angela said, them choosing it would be unexpected…Nasty dark tunnels are certainly off-putting π
LikeLiked by 2 people
I by far prefer to see where I’m going! πβ
LikeLiked by 2 people
Me too π
LikeLiked by 2 people
It’s a weird thing with us sighted beings
LikeLiked by 2 people